Tuckle is warned for FailRP as Terrry says "MRDM is ok when no one is looking" WHAT?

[Flexi]

In-Game Name

Tuckle Carlson

Your Steam ID

STEAM_0:0:1121404

Why were you banned or warned?

I was warned for FailRP. The FailRP was allegedly sky-basing while not being a preacher and building on the side walk.

Why should you be unwarned/unbanned?

1. My base was not in the sky.
2. Even if it was it's a public base and I have been told directly by IronFish(admin) that that was ok.
3. The person who warned me did not listen to me and showed favoritism towards the one who reported me. They are friends and clearly in a discord cal.
4. Terrry disregarded that I was told by someone who out ranked him that what I did was ok.
5. Terrry is highly biased against me as he has called me a whore and loser multiple times in TitsRP Discord Gen. I believe that all of this came about because they wanted to give me a warn.
6. I also believe this because someone was doing the same exact thing across the street and received no sit or warn.

You can't just expect me to know that just because IronFish isnt admin anymore that that means what he told me is now redacted (which i have been told by other staff now that IronFish's word still stands even after leaving.). That is unfair and wrong. Very disappointing behavior.

Who warned/banned you?

Terrry

How long were you warned or banned for?

it was a warn so i assume is on my record perma unless removed.

- Here is video evidence of the sit -

 

 

[AflictoGaming]

Yea to be honest here i dont see why you were warned for this at all, considering that post from iron, I am +1 for warn removal

This is not how staff should be acting

 

Please read the whole of ironfish' post "Staff allow them as long as they are NOT REPORTED and are a PUBLIC BASE. if you adhere to those TWO things, you SHOULD be able to do this for free.
 

Considering this is allowed until you are asked to remove it, i dont see why you were warned if you even said you would remove it because of the report made.

 

With this being made by iron Terrry could have asked you to remove it and all of you be on your way considering it wasn't hurting anything

Edited April 4, 2024 by AflictoGaming

[Aqua Nut]

+1 

                          Terrry is going through a clear case of targeting and social bias, whilst simultaneously slandering and disregarding the rules provided to him.

                          Showing a complete lack of understanding of the post *HE* reacted to, including complete ignorance of the a-ok Tuckle was given.

                          An unjust warn with transparent unprofessionalism. 

[Crumcrocs]

Yeah i agree with aqua you clearly knew what you said was wrong especially as a smod should have known better. +1

[Azria]

Even if I would hold bias against someone, I'd just not take a sit with them as its the professional thing to do. +1 For Warn Removal

Also Terrys intentions looked more like desire to harass Tuckle. I'm not suggesting anything in concern for Terry but someone needs to take a break.

[Tene]

hello im directly involved in the sit as i am the reporting player.

the evidence you linked that suggests its ''allowed'' clearly states exactly what terrry says; if someone reports someone, then it becomes an issue. If someone mass rdms and no one reports it, you do not get banned for it. This has been known, and we've had 3 smod discussions about it back when i was smod, each time agreeing that RDM, IRDM, MRDM etc is ALLOWED unless there is a report on the player.

Yes, you can mass rdm, but if you get a report, you are banned. That is what terrry is saying in this sit.


Please read the whole of ironfish' post "Staff allow them as long as they are NOT REPORTED and are a PUBLIC BASE. if you adhere to those TWO things, you SHOULD be able to do this for free.

its strange if you try and play this off as an accident too, as you have an english degree, so you should know how to read and comprehend what ironfish said. you intentionally not following what he said and only abiding by half his ruling is quite funny.

You did not adhere to these 2 things, only one of the 2, and in your own clip show that you were skybasing for 2 hours whilst building this, not as a preacher. you do this often and have a verbal from terry. imo as ex-smod and reporting player the warn is valid.

(also im not sure why u include our dms in here like it proves anything, u claimed someone was cheating on his girlfriend cause he told u there are pics of u online, and that u romantically rejected him because he said that? quite silly from u big 24.) 

all the dms from discord being used as evidence is troll because if u look into any of those situations its literally you lying about someones life/making false accusations to defame/get a reaction out of them. textbook drama mongering but i respect it, you like ur attention.


 

  

49 minutes ago, AflictoGaming said:

Yea to be honest here i dont see why you were warned for this at all, considering that post from iron, I am +1 for warn removal

This is not how staff should be acting

 

Please read the whole of ironfish' post "Staff allow them as long as they are NOT REPORTED and are a PUBLIC BASE. if you adhere to those TWO things, you SHOULD be able to do this for free.

so you're +1 even though she clearly went against what ironfish said - and as you've said yourself, read the whole thing, as long as they are NOT REPORTED. she was reported. how is terry in the wrong? 

  

  

51 minutes ago, Aqua Nut said:

+1 

                          Terrry is going through a clear case of targeting and social bias, whilst simultaneously slandering and disregarding the rules provided to him.

                          Showing a complete lack of understanding of the post *HE* reacted to, including complete ignorance of the a-ok Tuckle was given.

                          An unjust warn with transparent unprofessionalism. 

targeting by taking my sit. social bias by ? -- btw if you feel the person taking your sit is biased you're allowed to request a different staff member to take the sit, this was not done so im not sure how the bias argument comes out after she is warned, nor was any mention or hint of bias shown in the sit.

He showed a complete understanding of the post he reacted to, because he clearly explained what the post meant, and how ironfish also said that if there is a report the base is not allowed, the same with how RDM is allowed until there is a report. You can rdm your friend all you want but if he reports you the staff member will deal with it. tuckle wasnt given an ''a-ok'' ironfish said to use preacher job otherwise u can make it a public base but risk being reported for it.
warn was just.

 

  

48 minutes ago, crumcrocks said:

Yeah i agree with aqua you clearly knew what you said was wrong especially as a smod should have known better. +1

to talk about biased is 1 thing but this lazy of a reply from a moderator shows a lot.
It also just doesnt make sense, ''you clearly knew what you said was wrong especially as a smod'' ??????? what does this mean. thank god the staff team are giving comprehensible replies when giving their VOTE. lolol

 

Edited April 4, 2024 by Tene

[Chessmond]

First off I'm confused why you are mis using what I said about mrdm?  I said if no one calls a sit on mrdm its fine you dont have to punish for it. That was in response to you saying that no one else had a issue with your base. Tene (who called the sit) Had a issue with the base. You had another verbal warn for this by me from not that long ago. I would also like to point out that the post you all keep referencing states that if the base is reported it becomes a issue. Ironfish said this himself meaning that I didn't go against a recent admins word.

[Opila Bird]

A report was made on you and terrry took it, you are allowed to take sits of friends, and you are allowed to make sits on people you dont dislike, so please stay on topic. 

 

1 hour ago, LexiBird said:

1. My base was not in the sky.
2. Even if it was it's a public base and I have been told directly by IronFish(admin) that that was ok.

Your base was in the sky, whether it was on a ledge above the tunnel, that is still a skybase.
  
As well as this, lets look at what ironfish said.

On 12/23/2023 at 8:24 PM, Ironfish1 said:

     Hello! We already have a form of this implemented in the server. It's quite simple; make your sky base a public base, and make it out of the way(not blocking tunnels, or any high traffic areas). Staff usually allow them so long as they are not reported, and are a public base. If you adhere to those two things, you should be able to do this for free. The other alternative we already have implemented in the server is the preacher job.

 

Best Regards,
Danny Lee

 

Staff usually allow them so long as they are not reported, and a report was made. He told you to swap to preacher (a very simple request) and you instead chose to just completely delete your base. Thats your own decision, but just keeping the facts straight.

 

1 hour ago, LexiBird said:

3. The person who warned me did not listen to me and showed favoritism towards the one who reported me. They are friends and clearly in a discord cal.
4. Terrry disregarded that I was told by someone who out ranked him that what I did was ok.

I'm not quite sure how it is favoritism to warn you for something you've been warned for before. 

As I said above, terrry followed exactly what ironfish had said before.

 

1 hour ago, LexiBird said:

5. Terrry is highly biased against me as he has called me a whore and loser multiple times in TitsRP Discord Gen. I believe that all of this came about because they wanted to give me a warn.

If you have an issue with this make a forums report, it has nothing to do with this post.
 

 

1 hour ago, LexiBird said:

6. I also believe this because someone was doing the same exact thing across the street and received no sit or warn.

The other person wasn't reported, while terrry could have brought that person, they were afk and once again, not reported!

As a final note, stop editing your evidence in this way. Post the raw clip unedited or your evidence is to be null following forums guidelines.



Im an admin btw and im telling you youre wrong!

Edited April 4, 2024 by bugman

[AflictoGaming]

I do ask you dont post stuff not related to the warn appeal please

Edited April 4, 2024 by AflictoGaming

[Flexi]

so if I break ANY rule on the rules list and there is no report made then it's allowed.

EXAMPLE( i do not condone this): someone makes a pe** joke in ooc or talks about gross things in ooc but you dont explicitly get a report then it's ok?
Or do staff pick and chose what they intervene on? Do they pick and chose to take sits for only their friends when it's convenient or to fuck with someone?

The main point of contention is IF it was reported or not.  Every rule can be broken until someone types @ or posts on the forums. The optics on that is not the best....

So if you have punished someone who has made those kind of comments in ooc and weren't explicitly reported, should they be unbanned because they weren't reported?

 

The whole "well if it goes unreported" bull should be eliminated. How about staff do something when they see the rules in the motd that they seem to care about is broken.

Either you care about the rules or you don't.