ban appeal and warn removal

[Crabroll]

If you knew you were on thin ice already, why would you even bother doing something like this to someone you are not friends with.  If the staff member at the time believes that you had no RP reason to punch them and did it just to do damage to them and ran away after, it is within their power to punish you for this behavior. ESPECIALLY when you have such a history and is already on probation.

 

Let me reiterate why I would uphold a ban such as this.

 

1) your status of probation, u knew and u still did something dumb and pointless

2) your defence of this punch is that it doesn't do anything, while true, action alone is not the only aspect judged in the decision to punish you. Rather it is your intent, or lack of intent and rp reason.

3) your attitude in all of this. There isnt much to be explained. My message to you about your discord behavior while this is up just again, makes it so that no one wants to give you that mercy.

 

 

 

 

-1. If you even try to argue with me, I will close this ban appeal immediately. (we will take valid points but just taking what someone said to the literal definition of the word or nitpicking grammar/creating your own perspective through reading between the lines, not appreciated)

Edited June 1, 2023 by Crabroll

[DnChops]

crabrolls the only one that knows a single thing about moderation that has ever responded to one of my appeals before.

Only good response ive had.

And also its an appeal, ofc im going to respond to whatever people are going to say. its not an argument its a discussion.

Edited June 1, 2023 by DnChops

[DnChops]

appreciate you for adding that last part crabroll, but honestly, you would call a sit over ardm if it was a poop thrower considering it still does damage?

Do u not think this is the slightest bit biased after what me and bad had said to each other in ooc. and what i had said to terry. final response,  gonna check back tmrw or whenever to see the verdict. Green the senior moderator had agreed that shooting someone once and running away would be ardm, i did not. People in the discord server had also said something along the lines of ardm would be classed when damage is done no matter the intent, so i honestly do not see how using a poop thrower would be any different. could just be petty. is what it is.

[Ironfish1]

Hello DnChops! I would like to say that I have had minimal interactions with you, so I am coming at this completely unbiased. I personally believe this was all blown out of proportion just because of your past history or bad blood with other players/staff. In my complete and total honest opinion this is such a silly ban, even after watching the video. You got banned for 3 days for punching someone, running away, then dying. Even if the original punishment wasn't going to be a ban I still think a warn is way too extreme. I have given new players and older players alike verbals for MRDM (3 kills) due to the circumstances. Looking into this I can not see any reason for you being banned besides the fact that Chesmond had an issue with what you did because you were on probation. While I agree with all the other staff on the fact that you did ARDM, I think it's silly to an extent. ARDM that I would punish for would be someone trying to actually RDM someone, but just being dogwater at pvp. 

Quick Edit: Also there is the fact that you went eight days from being placed on your probationary period without breaking any rules (or atleast being reported for breaking them), only to end up being warned for this situation.

Due to all of these reasons I am a +1 for this appeal

 

Best Regards,

Ironfish1.

Edited June 1, 2023 by Ironfish1

[Succ The Zucc]

Literally this isn't even ARDM. This is just generalized minging which resulted in him dying anyways. I would have at most given him a warn (which is at most, given the probation it was moved to a 3 day ban which is while shitty for him still within your right to give it to him)

 

While I'm overall -1 for the appeal all I ask is that Chesmond actually write in the correct terminology for the action committed and change it to "Minging"

[The Worst Dad]

At most of what you should have gotten is just to be told to don't be a minge and don't go around punching people, as you're already on the thinnest of ice from being given a generous deal. But I am going to assume the sit was only made after you two were going at it in OOC. Punch your friends, don't punch people you don't know.

 

+1 for unban. As I can not remember a single time I have ever banned or warned a person for ARDM, and would have rather just spoken to the player. Minge or not.

[Spektor]

Yeah, I think this is kind of silly and a bit much for a punch.  Talking to would have seemed fine IMO. 

 

I don't know what went on in OOC, but this seems kinda emotionally charged.  If you kept doing it then yeah, minging.  But otherwise Hobo Dad said it all.   

 

+1 unban 

[DnChops]

"3) your attitude in all of this. There isnt much to be explained. My message to you about your discord behavior while this is up just again, makes it so that no one wants to give you that mercy." @Crabroll

A mod should not judge someone by what they have said to them or what they have said to other people. Or even by what they have done (unrelated to the "ardm"). That is called being biased. One of the aspects of being a moderator is being completely unbiased even if you hold a grudge against the person. Honestly doubt he would have brought me into that sit if i was anyone else/did not have that conflict with him in ooc.

Edited June 1, 2023 by DnChops

[Coconut Overflow]

Hello DnChops! After reading this appeal, I believe the best course of action would be to educate you so that you do not make these mistakes like this in the future. Punching someone and running away has no roleplay value whatsoever. This is textbook minging, and is against our rules. The issue I have with this entire situation is if the probationary period didn't exist, there is no doubt in my mind nothing would come out of this, at most a verbal warning, so you know for the future not to do this. You were 100% in the wrong for doing this, and I don't want this to come off as what you did was within the rules. With this in mind, this is my decision.

You appeal has been accepted, and you will have your ban removed. You will receive a verbal for minging, and your probation will resume as normal. The probation ends June 7th.

ACCEPTED