Report on Mentor Peanut Butter

[Bosco the Unicycling Bear]

Your Steam Name: umadbro12315

Your Ingame Name: [HS] Mr Bosco The Dovahbear

Your SteamProfile/SteamID

Who are you reporting? (Their name and profile):  http://steamcommunity.com/id/ggodanubis/ Mentor Peanut Butter

 

Reasons Why you are reporting: Abuse of power. He had a police checkpoint set up, it wasn't in use, he was AFK, but it still separated the main traffic area of the town infront of CP. I vote demote him, the demote passes, 10 mins or so later he brings me, and asks me why I demoted him. I tell him why and he tells me it is a false reason, I quickly explain it is an RP reason for hindering the flow of traffic and blocking main paths. He tells me it is not. He was about to warn me, as you can see, but he changes his mind, probably realizing I would report him. We take the argument to pm's after I tell him I would have reported him if he warned me. He did the same thing to troll man after troll demoted him, aswell. We take the argument to pm's, and I tell him the scenario and talk Krypto and I had a while back with Famous Afrikan Cuisine. He says Krypto does not make the rules and I show that nowhere in the rules does it go against what I said, only says you can demote for RP reasons. He then tells me he will mute me if I keep arguing when there is an easy ignore option.

 

Evidence: 

https://ibb.co/dH9YSy

https://ibb.co/gO7yud 

https://ibb.co/mn5wfJ

[Mr. Peanut Butter]

I had been building a CP Checkpoint for hours, as my job allows it and I prefer to build when there are not a whole lot of people on. I had to get up to empty the trash irl before the garbage truck got here, so I tried to hurry up and dupe it but it was unfinished and taking too long to weld, so I had to go AFK. The checkpoints doors were left no collided while I was AFK. I came back and saw i was demoted. I brought the user to a sit and they said their demote was valid simply because it is an RP reason and not a demote for a server rule or etc, but I explained that demoting for a false RP Reason is still a false demote, and that their reason was false because I was in fact NOT blocking the path as it was no collided while I was AFK and most of the time I was BUILDING the checkpoint, therefore I was NOT hindering RP as their demote reason claimed, nor should it ever be considered valid to demote somebody for performing a job function. I instructed them not to demote me for that again and that I was only trying to build and not even using the building for RP or RPing myself yet. I checked their warns using !warns menu to make sure they did not have a history of false demoting people. They didn't, so I returned them and tried to go on about my business.  They would not accept this and said that they would have reported me had I warned them. I explained it again and even made comparisons to other jobs such as how kidnapping hinders RP but you cannot just demote someone for kidnapping you, especially if it is part of their job. They still would not accept my reasoning so I asked them to just stop messaging me about it. They continued to message me after that, so I asked them a second time to stop messaging me, this time telling them if they were to continue that I would just mute them. They stopped messaging me after this.

[Bosco the Unicycling Bear]

I had been building a CP Checkpoint for hours, as my job allows it and I prefer to build when there are not a whole lot of people on. I had to get up to empty the trash irl before the garbage truck got here, so I tried to hurry up and dupe it but it was unfinished and taking too long to weld, so I had to go AFK. The checkpoints doors were left no collided while I was AFK. I came back and saw i was demoted. I brought the user to a sit and they said their demote was valid simply because it is an RP reason and not a demote for a server rule or etc, but I explained that demoting for a false RP Reason is still a false demote, and that their reason was false because I was in fact NOT blocking the path as it was no collided while I was AFK and most of the time I was BUILDING the checkpoint, therefore I was NOT hindering RP as their demote reason claimed, nor should it ever be considered valid to demote somebody for performing a job function. I instructed them not to demote me for that again and that I was only trying to build and not even using the building for RP or RPing myself yet. I checked their warns using !warns menu to make sure they did not have a history of false demoting people. They didn't, so I returned them and tried to go on about my business.  They would not accept this and said that they would have reported me had I warned them. I explained it again and even made comparisons to other jobs such as how kidnapping hinders RP but you cannot just demote someone for kidnapping you, especially if it is part of their job. They still would not accept my reasoning so I asked them to just stop messaging me about it. They continued to message me after that, so I asked them a second time to stop messaging me, this time telling them if they were to continue that I would just mute them. They stopped messaging me after this.

 

Before you left, it was NOT no collided, which you admitted in your response. And it isn't false. Even if they were no collided, it was one small path of it which was no collided, and it blocked the whole road. And when you said kidnapping hinders RP, I said it is their one job. They have no other job. CP don't have to set up checkpoints, as they still have a purpose if they don't. They can see the whole chat above, so there is no point in us telling our stories, as they will make their own assumptions based on the evidence I provided.

[Mr. Peanut Butter]

It wasn't nocollided for a while because I didn't want to dupe it wwith nocollides and have to re collide every time I place the dupe in the future. I was in game when they were collided and i was allowing people through to the best of my ability while also still trying to work on it to dupe it.

The doors are big enough that vehicles can fit through and people most definitely can, so no it was not blocking ANYONE at the time of the demote.

[Bosco the Unicycling Bear]

It wasn't nocollided for a while because I didn't want to dupe it wwith nocollides and have to re collide every time I place the dupe in the future. I was in game when they were collided and i was allowing people through to the best of my ability while also still trying to work on it to dupe it.

The doors are big enough that vehicles can fit through and people most definitely can, so no it was not blocking ANYONE at the time of the demote.

 

It doesn't take that long to dupe, just max out area size, shift right click, then right click again.

[Doc McStubbins�]

Mentor, try to make your pathways and openings more clear. Bosco, this has gone a bit too far, and didn't warrant a report, rather a logical discussion in game. Demoting him in the first place was a bit far, but I can see where both parties were in the right.

 

This is ending now. 

 

RESOLUTION: Reported player was coached/advised, and reporting player has gotten their point across. No further action is to be taken.

 

ACCEPTED