I think it should be easier for Spirit Caller to get dark spirits. They're so difficult to obtain as high bounty criminals tend to just be MRDMers or BHunters zooming around, and they'll not have 75+ pooled xp Either just alternative means (rarely when fishing?) or a lower threshold for dark spirits cos you need both light and dark for a talisman.
There is currently nearly 200 light spirit jars, and 4 dark spirit jars in my inventory, but like 60-70 random talismans in my bank. There's pretty much no reason to play Spirit Caller when treasure hunter is better and faster at getting talismans, even hobo can get talismans more consistently by just buying t1 lootboxes after digging through 6~ dumpsters due to the issues listed above.
Talismans also follow vague categories so it would be nice for a third type of optional influence catalyst for the talisman, and talismans only the Spirit Caller can make.
Working titles for the catalysts, but could be something like:
Police Catalyst
Criminal Catalyst
Production Catalyst
Body Catalyst
Unique talisman ideas:
bullet spread reduction
Teleport to in front of PD
Eat PUBs for longer (stacks with gang perk)
Stun Kidnapper away when they attempt to knock you out, +1 resist (stacks with hard hat, cooldown is 15 mins, stun effect is until death)
Gain armor when you restore health
Food heals for more and food effect duration is tripled
Chance to catch multiple fish when fishing
Your planted crops will damage a pig that eats them by a lot